Tbhk Theory - Tumblr Posts

Okay im dumb its probs m1tsuba.

However, YOU NEVER KNOW- after all, No.1s abilities work less well on supernaturals.

Anyways, another random thought! What are the chances of mei remembering her mystery counterpart?? :D

Honestly as a shijima mei fan I would really really like it if aidalro decided to take that path. Especially since our last interaction with her was years ago.

So, I haven’t read tbhk chapter 112 yet, but I HAVE seen some panels circulating on tumblr and I had a little thought…

Specifically after I saw this panel.

Is the revived mitsuba in this panel m1tsuba or m2tsuba?

Because if m1tsuba (yknow, the human) was alive and m2tsuba (the supernatural) never existed in this alternate reality…

How would kou react? And assuming that they return to the reality with m2tsuba, how would this affect the current mitsukou dynamic?

There’s been many mitsukou analyses on tumblr, so I won’t talk about it here, but this might bring their dynamic back to square one. And plenty of angst. It would be very interesting to see :D

Also, I refuse to believe that this is the end of tbhk.

:D

No but in the arc where we find out about the clock keepers and nene’s lifespan(I forgot what it was called) it is stated that the clock keepers abilities do not work as effectively on supernaturals. What does this mean. WHAT DOES THIS MEAN.

I feel that it would be dissappointing if shijima/mitsuba was actually alive and their mystery selves don’t exist at all in this present, period. With no memories coming back to them. Or anything, really.

Aidalro what are the ramifications of this I am in your walls

Aidalro tell me

"You'll be a great exorcist one day. "

Manga Spoilers ahead

In this scene Hanako didn't just say this to tease Kou because he obviously meant it. Either the wound is because he's still weak (because he's been locked away before) or Kou really has potential but because he lacks experience he can't wield it properly. This can be tied to the theory going around that Kou may be involved in Yashiro's death (hopefully not.)

Anyways, let's be honest. If they weren't fighting this would be a wholesome scene lol

I know I'm late in posting this haha but better late than never (it's been sitting in my drafts for a while now and I feel bad.) Also, I don't really remember this detail in the manga so we're not sure if this really means anything (I blame my bad memory, it sucks so bad)

I'd like to add that maybe tsukasa merged with the house like mitsuba merging with the 3rd mystery— we've seen tsukasa ya know.. Cause mitsuba to uhh replace the 3rd mystery by devouring it technically, so maybe the same happened or fake tsukasa knows how to merge them

So, theory time. This focuses a lot on events that have been animated, a.k.a season 1, if more information for it, either to confirm or deny it, appear I might expand it but honestly, it's not that big of a theory and most likely not accurate but it has been occupying my mind. Plus, I don't think it'll ever get touched upon. Also, if someone has said this, I have not seen it anywhere.

So, let me start!

A Yugi twins plus Minamoto family theory, I call it "Trapped". And it's based on three panels.

Chapter 3 in the manga, when Kou was first introduced...

Chapter 17 in the manga, right after Tsukasa was introduced...

How do these two fit? Well, it's what they say in these panels that made me think.

You see, when Kou was introduced and said his grandma trapped Hanako. At first I thought "oh, so like trapped him to the toilet?" But then this little extra panel exists...

Yes, Yashiro asks why he's called 'Hanako-san' but it's still referring to him being to the girl's bathrooms. So, with this, he's not trapped to the toilet, maybe he is by the rumors but he was not trapped by the Minamoto grandma.

But where does Tsukasa fit? Well, he said, after being introduced, for the first time on the roof, "I can't move too well".

Why can't he move well? Was he, perhaps, trapped? Trapped by the Minamoto grandma? But then, Kou described Hanako, so why would it be Tsukasa?

They look extremely alike. Except for the sticker (and maybe the teeth), they look the same. You can say the clothes are different but it's not like Tsukasa hasn't dressed like his brother before. Literally was introduced with Hanako's clothing.

So, what if, somehow, he learned that Hanako was being "hunted" and took his place? He wouldn't even need to do much, just dress like him, maybe have a kitchen knife with him, though not necessary, and pretend to be him.

The Minamoto family could have just heard of Hanako-san rumors or bc of who they are, they did their research, bases like name, weapon, maybe abilities. Since the wonders are supposed to be murders, it would be assumed, right off the bat that they have killed.

Everything could be said and be accurate about Hanako and yet the one that got trapped could have been Tsukasa.

Another and final panel would be this...

Chapter 20 in the manga, second time Tsukasa and Hanako see each other...

Hanako could have very well avoided Tsukasa for 10, 20, maybe even 30 years. Meaning, it could be 100% possible that Tsukasa was the one trapped but of course, it's not like he would say it.

Or Hanako was simply trapped for a bit and that was it. I don't know. My brain likes to think things that might not make any sense or be true.

I'll take my leave...

Bye! 🙈

What a fascinating thing it is to re-read something.

A while back, I had a theory about Kou and Yashiro messing with the timeline. More specifically, putting in motion the events of the yugi twins lives. That was back in December 2021, and I never ended up posting that theory. (it's still in my drafts)

The reason I'm bringing it up is because of recent events in the manga and a little theory of what the clock keepers changed.

Spoilers

It's fairly obvious that Hanako or Amane, more precisely, never killed Tsukasa, meaning that the 4 years old Tsukasa that Kou and Yashiro met in the red house never went back.

If it hasn't clicked yet...

I think the clock keepers changed a present type of event rather than a past one. Since Tsukasa in the new present still seems to be possessed and Amane lived beyond his 13 years old self (and got possessed as well wtf), it means that they never changed the event of Amane killing Tsukasa because it never happened. No, they changed Kou and Yashiro ever meeting toddler Tsukasa in the red house.

Tsukasa returned because Kou told him that Amane died at 13 and killed him as well. If the event of Yashiro and Kou going in the house had never happened in the first place, then the young boy would never go back. And in the new present, he didn't. Something else is going on with the both of them [Tsukasa, Amane] this time around, sure, but I do believe that at least one of the core things the clock keepers changed was that meeting in the red house.

Don't think I'm the first one to point this out. I just have a wack timing for it since I keep these things to myself.

TBHK theory PT.1

Tsukasa is trying to grant Amane’s and Nene’s wish, this would also mean that Tsukasa remembers Nene’s from the red house!!

When Nene goes to the red house with Kou, Tsukasa tells Nene that they are the same after after he finds out that Nene has feelings for Amane.

(Implying that they share the same wish to know more about Amane.)

Tsukasa then takes Nene to Amane’s old bed room, saying that HE will tell her about Amane. Telling her about how Amane was sick, Tsukasa’s first wish to that “god”.

How he made the first trade with the “god” and how he had traded his life for Amane’s.

When he finds out that Amane is going to kill him, Tsukasa is surprised.

After Tsukasa decides to go back with to Amane, he says that he will write a letter to Kou and Nene which we still haven’t seen yet however I bet this will be brought up soon.

Tsukasa then goes back to his own timeline with that “god”.

With Kou and Nene, we see the house is now burnt to the ground. Which means that the time that they were in (the room they had set on fire) was when the house had been destroyed and had set the “god” free from that house.

(It was bounded there and unable to leave so it left with Tsukasa. Basically bonding itself onto Tsukasa)

A few years later, 7 year old Amane met Nene at the Star festival, having dinner with her and watching the fireworks together. This is when Amane had started to get feeling for Nene, wanting her not to leave when she finds a way back home.

Now, instead of Amane writing on his wish card that he wants to be an astronaut. He writes “I wish to met Nene again!”

Which got the attention of Tsukasa, once Amane had gotten into high school. He didn’t talk to anyone nor did he make friends.

Ever sense his first year, Amane continuously gets wounds on his arms and more come up every single day. Amane’s teacher, Tsuchigomori thinks that Amane may be getting bullied.

Then Amane basically says that even if no one else would forgive it. He would.

Now, everyone in the community thinks that Amane WAS bullied due to Ysuchigomori asking him who is doing this to him.

However this is NOT the case, Amane is doing this to himself. How do I know this? Well look at the wounds.

They aren’t just any wounds. They are wounds from fixing the clock.

Amane Yugi was never bullied, he was getting hurt by the clock which he couldn’t tell Tsuchigomori about due to the fact that no one is meant to be touching the clock..

TBHK THOERY PT.2

Amane Yugi was never bullied, he was getting hurt by the clock which he couldn't tell Tsuchigomori about due to the fact that no one is meant to be touching the clock.

Amane was so determined to get the clock moving by the end of the year that he didn’t care if he was hurting himself.

Now we can say that Tsukasa is the reason Amane is fixing the clock due to the fact that Tsukasa tells Nene about No.1's power.

Also asking her if she wants to still learn about Amane and telling her to come play with him again if she does.

Now this is where it's a bit blurry, cause Tsukasa KNEW the clock keeps would create a new timeline so then Nene COULD play with him once again. However the problem is that, what was the game?

Trying to get out of the pit? Cause if so, Nene will lose due to the fact she no longer has her fish form.

Or maybe it was traumatising Kou with his wishes? Or maybe it was the fact someone actually came, to see him and wanted to learn about him and Amane.

Tbh, I’m still not sure myself… but anyways.

I didn't forget the fact that I said that "Tsukasa remembers Nene" cause in reality. He does, we don't know why or how but from The Tea Party arc.

Tsukasa is asking her questions as if he know Nene liked Amane.

When he hears that Nene doesn't, he takes Nene to the everywhere and nowhere boundary where Nene mets Amane for the first time and this is when Amane loses his keys.

Running out of the room.

Now if you look at the date, this was 4 days BEFORE Amane gives Tsuchigomori the moon rock.

Now this was on a Friday so for Monday and Tuesday. Amane was hard at work, trying to fix the clock. Which is why his wounds are worse than before in Tsuchigomori's flashback.

(I am still working on this theory so please, if you have anything to add. Please do tell!! <3)